Maharaj: By all means pray for the dead. It pleases them very much. They are flattered.
— I Am That
Really?!?!
Friday, April 16, 2010
...it's either everything, or it's nothing...
Questioner: If the unconditioned cannot be experienced, for all experience is conditioned, then why talk of it at all?
Maharaj: How can there be knowledge of the conditioned without the unconditioned? There must be a source from which all this flows, a foundation on which all stands. Self-realization is primarily the knowledge of one's conditioning and the awareness that the infinite variety of conditions depends on our infinite ability to be conditioned and to give rise to variety. To the conditioned mind the unconditioned appears as the totality as well as the absence of everything. Neither can be directly experienced, but this does not make it non-existent.
- I Am That
I have pondered the concept of infinity at length in my life - it is probably the single most potent concept that rattles around in my head. I agree that if we accept that infinity is (which I absolutely do), then it is reasonable to deduce that the unconditioned also is, noting that the word is is totally inadequate in both of these clauses. Nonetheless, I find no support for either the claim that knowledge of the conditioned must imply the unconditioned, or that there must be a source from which "all this" flows. Still, I think I sort of see the perspective of the overall, even if the translation may have been severely challenged: obviously, an existent unconditioned is an oxymoron.
Maharaj: How can there be knowledge of the conditioned without the unconditioned? There must be a source from which all this flows, a foundation on which all stands. Self-realization is primarily the knowledge of one's conditioning and the awareness that the infinite variety of conditions depends on our infinite ability to be conditioned and to give rise to variety. To the conditioned mind the unconditioned appears as the totality as well as the absence of everything. Neither can be directly experienced, but this does not make it non-existent.
- I Am That
I have pondered the concept of infinity at length in my life - it is probably the single most potent concept that rattles around in my head. I agree that if we accept that infinity is (which I absolutely do), then it is reasonable to deduce that the unconditioned also is, noting that the word is is totally inadequate in both of these clauses. Nonetheless, I find no support for either the claim that knowledge of the conditioned must imply the unconditioned, or that there must be a source from which "all this" flows. Still, I think I sort of see the perspective of the overall, even if the translation may have been severely challenged: obviously, an existent unconditioned is an oxymoron.
seeing without reference
Maharaj: The refulsal to see the snake in the rope is the necessary condition for seeing the rope.
— I Am That
But, first one must see something. As with seeing fruit in the trees, one must see something or have some idea (memory) of what to look for. Some believe that when Christopher Columbus first landed in America, the native people did not see his ships because they had no frame of reference, memory, of there existing such an object as a ship and it was a wise man of some kind who recognized a change in the water and deduced there must be something there. If I have never seen anything similar to a rope other than a rope, I am likely to only see a rope and be befuddled by why it is moving. That I might observe movement and consider that the object is not a rope is certainly not a given. At least, not in existential reality.
— I Am That
But, first one must see something. As with seeing fruit in the trees, one must see something or have some idea (memory) of what to look for. Some believe that when Christopher Columbus first landed in America, the native people did not see his ships because they had no frame of reference, memory, of there existing such an object as a ship and it was a wise man of some kind who recognized a change in the water and deduced there must be something there. If I have never seen anything similar to a rope other than a rope, I am likely to only see a rope and be befuddled by why it is moving. That I might observe movement and consider that the object is not a rope is certainly not a given. At least, not in existential reality.
Earnestness
Maharaj: ...if you are shallow and impatient, not earnest enough to look and wait, you are like a child crying for the moon.
— I Am That
What source this earnestness? What is its motivator? What kindles faith and belief and trust? What hope without them?
— I Am That
What source this earnestness? What is its motivator? What kindles faith and belief and trust? What hope without them?
fear is the only obstacle
Maharaj: ...there is a connection...between the action and its motive. Spiritual practice is will asserted and re-asserted... Unwillingness born out of fear is the only obstacle.
— I Am That
What of sloth and torpor born of doubt or the absence of conviction? Doesn't true spiritual practice require desire or conviction - typically brought on by pain or the innate human need to fill the hole or have purpose? Where is motivation?
— I Am That
What of sloth and torpor born of doubt or the absence of conviction? Doesn't true spiritual practice require desire or conviction - typically brought on by pain or the innate human need to fill the hole or have purpose? Where is motivation?
Faith
Questioner: Would you tell a Westerner to repeat "Om" or "Ram" or "Hare Krishna" ceaselessly, though he lacks completely the faith and conviction... Without confidence of fervor; repeating mechanically the same sounds, will he ever achieve anything?
Maharaj: Why not? It is the urge, the hidden motive that matters, not the shape it takes. Whatever he does, if he does it for the sake of finding his own real self, will surely bring him to himself.
Questioner: No need of faith in the efficacy of the means?
Maharaj: No need of faith which is but expectation of results. Here the action only counts. Whatever you do for the sake of truth, will take you to truth. Only be earnest and honest. The shape it takes hardly matters.
— I Am That
Mustn't I have faith that doing whatever for the sake of truth will take me to truth? Perhaps faith that some practice is right without expectation of some specific results - that makes sense to me. But, why would one undertake any action without some faith that it is the right thing to do and at least the expectation that whatever comes of it will be somehow good or appropriate?
Maharaj: Why not? It is the urge, the hidden motive that matters, not the shape it takes. Whatever he does, if he does it for the sake of finding his own real self, will surely bring him to himself.
Questioner: No need of faith in the efficacy of the means?
Maharaj: No need of faith which is but expectation of results. Here the action only counts. Whatever you do for the sake of truth, will take you to truth. Only be earnest and honest. The shape it takes hardly matters.
— I Am That
Mustn't I have faith that doing whatever for the sake of truth will take me to truth? Perhaps faith that some practice is right without expectation of some specific results - that makes sense to me. But, why would one undertake any action without some faith that it is the right thing to do and at least the expectation that whatever comes of it will be somehow good or appropriate?
Ripening
Maharaj: You seem to want instant insight, forgeting that the instant is always preceded by a long preparation. The fruit falls suddenly, but the ripening takes time.
— I Am That
Do we get to know that we are fermenting?
— I Am That
Do we get to know that we are fermenting?
Monday, April 12, 2010
and the arisen fermentation of ignorance increases
Sabbasava Sutta: All the Fermentations
"...one of six kinds of view arises in him..."
"...one of six kinds of view arises in him..."
Sunday, April 11, 2010
Just to experience
Maharaj: ...At the root of consciousness lies desire, the urge to experience.
— I Am That
If this statement is true on a very simple level, then wouldn't any experience be equally satisfying? Whether pleasant or painful, any experience would be good. Craving and aversion become equal as long as they are felt, or experienced. The curiosity then is not that one person says to another, "Yuck, this stinks! Here, smell this."; rather, that the other person leans over and smells it. Shock jocks have good ratings because they create emotion in people. The most outrageous material on YouTube is watched the most. Sitcoms do well whether they invoke laughter of cause us to cringe when somebody is horribly embarrassed. People form into groups with no apparent purpose other than to hate somebody else. Even something as mundane as the news no longer cares about the news as it is that which causes the greatest emotion - whether aversion, pity, outrage or fear - that sells.
Perhaps we don't seek happiness, we simply need to feel.
— I Am That
If this statement is true on a very simple level, then wouldn't any experience be equally satisfying? Whether pleasant or painful, any experience would be good. Craving and aversion become equal as long as they are felt, or experienced. The curiosity then is not that one person says to another, "Yuck, this stinks! Here, smell this."; rather, that the other person leans over and smells it. Shock jocks have good ratings because they create emotion in people. The most outrageous material on YouTube is watched the most. Sitcoms do well whether they invoke laughter of cause us to cringe when somebody is horribly embarrassed. People form into groups with no apparent purpose other than to hate somebody else. Even something as mundane as the news no longer cares about the news as it is that which causes the greatest emotion - whether aversion, pity, outrage or fear - that sells.
Perhaps we don't seek happiness, we simply need to feel.
Maharaj: The witness only registers events. In the abeyance of the mind, even the sense "I am" dissolves. There is no "I am" without the mind.
[snip]
Maharaj: The witness merely registers the presence or absence of experience. It is not an experience by itself, but it becomes an experience when the thought: "I am the witness", arises.
[snip]
Maharaj: Call it silence, or void, or abeyance, the fact is that the three — experiencer, experiencing, experience — are not. In witnessing, in awareness, self-consciousness, the sense of being this or that, is not. Unidentified being remains.
[snip]
Maharaj: When I think of it — it becomes an experience.
[snip]
Maharaj: Your difficulty stems from the idea that reality is a state of consciousness,...
— I Am That
Awareness without being aware of awareness, or a something being aware? Witnessing without a witnesser? Even observance without an observation? "I think, therefore I am". Otherwise, I Am, but I don't think, therefore, I am't, but I Am. OK, got it.
[snip]
Maharaj: The witness merely registers the presence or absence of experience. It is not an experience by itself, but it becomes an experience when the thought: "I am the witness", arises.
[snip]
Maharaj: Call it silence, or void, or abeyance, the fact is that the three — experiencer, experiencing, experience — are not. In witnessing, in awareness, self-consciousness, the sense of being this or that, is not. Unidentified being remains.
[snip]
Maharaj: When I think of it — it becomes an experience.
[snip]
Maharaj: Your difficulty stems from the idea that reality is a state of consciousness,...
— I Am That
Awareness without being aware of awareness, or a something being aware? Witnessing without a witnesser? Even observance without an observation? "I think, therefore I am". Otherwise, I Am, but I don't think, therefore, I am't, but I Am. OK, got it.
Nice metaphor
Questioner: ...If I am blind from birth and you tell me that you know things without touching them, while I must touch to know, I am aware that I am blind without knowing what it means to see.
— I Am That
— I Am That
Getting ready
This morning during meditation the question popped into my mind, "Am I ready for I to be enlightened?" Maybe the practice is not to become liberated, but only to become ready. That is why people reportedly practice (or struggle) for a long time, then liberation comes in a flash. Later today, I encountered this tidbit:
Maharaj: Everything happens all the time, but you must be ready for it. Readiness is ripeness. You do not see the real because your mind is not ready for it. — I Am That
Like I needed some eerie confirmation..
Maharaj: Everything happens all the time, but you must be ready for it. Readiness is ripeness. You do not see the real because your mind is not ready for it. — I Am That
Like I needed some eerie confirmation..
Stubborness
Questioner: I am not your projection, nor are you miine. I am in my own right, not merely as your creation. This crude philosophy of imagination and projection does not appeal to me. You are depriving me of all reality. Who is the image of whom? You are my image or am I yours? Or am I an image in my own image! No, something is wrong somewhere.
— I Am That
Sounds a little silly heard coming from somebody else.
— I Am That
Sounds a little silly heard coming from somebody else.
What doesn't die?
Questioner: What dies with death?
Maharaj: The idea "I am this body" dies; the witness does not.
— I Am That
Maharaj: The idea "I am this body" dies; the witness does not.
— I Am That
Thursday, April 8, 2010
And the Self begat self...
"The observable is in the mind. The nature of the self is pure awareness, pure witnessing, unaffected by the presence or absence of knowledge or liking." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Who is the possessor of pure awareness, the witnesseser of pure witnessing? How can the infinite unmanifest have any characteristics or behavior? Are we back at the "self->Self->unmanifest" trinity? Meanwhile, the Buddha's dependent origination suggests that everything starts with ignorance. In Nisargadatta's description, I guess the Self was manifest from the unmanifest beyond and everything was peachy while Self was pure awareness until it turned into the prime ignoramus and begat self.
Who is the possessor of pure awareness, the witnesseser of pure witnessing? How can the infinite unmanifest have any characteristics or behavior? Are we back at the "self->Self->unmanifest" trinity? Meanwhile, the Buddha's dependent origination suggests that everything starts with ignorance. In Nisargadatta's description, I guess the Self was manifest from the unmanifest beyond and everything was peachy while Self was pure awareness until it turned into the prime ignoramus and begat self.
In the beginning...
Questioner: In the ultimate state there can be no happiness?
Maharaj: Nor sorrow. Only freedom. Happiness depends on something or other and can be lost; freedom from everything depends on nothing and cannot be lost. Freedom from sorrow has no cause and, therefore, cannot be destroyed. Realize that freedom.
— I Am That
Then, how did I get here if, before being, I was free? It is one thing to say that there was no beginning, or that we cannot know how things began; but, it is quite another to say that the beginning could not have occurred.
Maharaj: Nor sorrow. Only freedom. Happiness depends on something or other and can be lost; freedom from everything depends on nothing and cannot be lost. Freedom from sorrow has no cause and, therefore, cannot be destroyed. Realize that freedom.
— I Am That
Then, how did I get here if, before being, I was free? It is one thing to say that there was no beginning, or that we cannot know how things began; but, it is quite another to say that the beginning could not have occurred.
more restlessness
Questioner: ...is it true that all existence is painful?
Maharaj: What else can be the cause of this universal search for pleasure? Does a happy man seek happiness? How restless people are, how constantly on the move! It is because they are in pain that they seek relief in pleasure. All the happiness they can imagine is in the assurance of repeated pleasure.
[...snip...]
Maharaj: What is birth and death but the beginning and the ending of a stream of events in consciousness?...we build castles in the air hoping for endless pleasure which we call happiness.
— I Am That
Maharaj: What else can be the cause of this universal search for pleasure? Does a happy man seek happiness? How restless people are, how constantly on the move! It is because they are in pain that they seek relief in pleasure. All the happiness they can imagine is in the assurance of repeated pleasure.
[...snip...]
Maharaj: What is birth and death but the beginning and the ending of a stream of events in consciousness?...we build castles in the air hoping for endless pleasure which we call happiness.
— I Am That
Help
"The only help worth giving is freeing from the need for further help. Repeated help is no help at all. Do not talk of helping another, unless you can put him beyond all need of help." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Stop, just stop
"For many years you sought your peace of mind. You could not find it, for a thing essentially restless cannot be at peace." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Seeking implies restlessness? Yes, I guess it does. How often have I thought the human need for a purpose in life is itself an aberration. So, is spiritual seeking any different? Is noble seeking an exception, or just more restlessness due to the unsatisfactoriness of life.
Seeking implies restlessness? Yes, I guess it does. How often have I thought the human need for a purpose in life is itself an aberration. So, is spiritual seeking any different? Is noble seeking an exception, or just more restlessness due to the unsatisfactoriness of life.
ॐ
"Both mind and body are intermittent states. The sum total of these flashes creates the illusion of existence" - Nisargadatta, I Am That
How do we get from temporal to intermittent? Even if I am a bag of vibrations, they are analog. Don't digitize me.
(In spite of advancing technology's attempt to digitize everything, nature is still wonderfully analog. One day the physicists stuck on string theory are going to hear a scruffy sadhu from India comment that the universe is just a vibration and the sound is Om and suddenly declare, "Holy shit! We understand everything!".)
How do we get from temporal to intermittent? Even if I am a bag of vibrations, they are analog. Don't digitize me.
(In spite of advancing technology's attempt to digitize everything, nature is still wonderfully analog. One day the physicists stuck on string theory are going to hear a scruffy sadhu from India comment that the universe is just a vibration and the sound is Om and suddenly declare, "Holy shit! We understand everything!".)
because the flame is not extinguished
Maharaj: There are no needs, desires only.
Questioner: To eat, to drink, to shelter one's body; to live?
Maharaj: The desire to live is the one fundamental desire. All else depends on it.
Questioner: We live, because we must.
Maharaj: we live, because we crave sensory existence.
— I Am That
Questioner: To eat, to drink, to shelter one's body; to live?
Maharaj: The desire to live is the one fundamental desire. All else depends on it.
Questioner: We live, because we must.
Maharaj: we live, because we crave sensory existence.
— I Am That
Clean up the past and...
"To go beyond the body you must be healthy; to go beyond the mind, you must have your mind in perfrect order. You cannot leave a mess behind and go beyond." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
The most succinct reason from practicing the eight-fold path, and everything else we do.
The most succinct reason from practicing the eight-fold path, and everything else we do.
If I could change the world...
"It is neither necessary, nor possible to change others. But if you can change yourself you will find that no other change is needed." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Old advice, but well worth revisiting.
There's the right way, and then there's my way... :)
"A dim-sighted man will not see the parrot on the branch of a tree, however much you may prompt him to look. At best he will see your pointed finger. First purify your vision, learn to see instead of staring, and you will perceive the parrot. " - Nisargadatta, I Am That
In other words, stop partaking of the teachings of gurus or masters and go meditate until I have no need of gurus and masters. Harrumph.
In other words, stop partaking of the teachings of gurus or masters and go meditate until I have no need of gurus and masters. Harrumph.
Wednesday, April 7, 2010
A state of pure awareness
"To be a living being is not the ultimate state; there is something beyond; much more wonderful, which is neither being nor non-being, neither living nor not-living. It is a state of pure awareness, beyond the limitations of space and time. Once the illusion that the body-mind is oneself is abandoned, death loses its terror, it becomes a part of living." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Even allowing for the inadequacy of language to express the indescribable, the "state of pure awareness" still leaves me asking how awareness can be in the unmanifest beyond. Doesn't this suggest that "I Am" persists in the beyond and can somehow be this "pure awareness"? Western thinking gives us the adage "God is either everything or he is nothing". This seems to suggest that "God is both everything and nothing, and I Am God".
Even allowing for the inadequacy of language to express the indescribable, the "state of pure awareness" still leaves me asking how awareness can be in the unmanifest beyond. Doesn't this suggest that "I Am" persists in the beyond and can somehow be this "pure awareness"? Western thinking gives us the adage "God is either everything or he is nothing". This seems to suggest that "God is both everything and nothing, and I Am God".
ADD: Acceptable Duality Disorder
Questioner: All my waking and dreaming I am conscious of myself. It does not help me much.
Maharaj: You were aware of thinking, feeling, doing. You were not aware of your being.
Questioner: What is the new factor you want me to bring in?
Maharaj: The attitude of pure witnessing, of watching the events without taking part in them.
— I Am That
Somehow, this makes me thing of schizophrenia or multiple personality disorders. I have had this happen in myself where I was involved in a discussion that became heated and part of me stepped back and calmly witnessed the outward part of me becoming angry. It was interesting and the witness even thought it a bit comical, but it didn't really feel all that healthy. At least, it left me wondering if unskillful use of such an ability could lead to serious problems.
Maharaj: You were aware of thinking, feeling, doing. You were not aware of your being.
Questioner: What is the new factor you want me to bring in?
Maharaj: The attitude of pure witnessing, of watching the events without taking part in them.
— I Am That
Somehow, this makes me thing of schizophrenia or multiple personality disorders. I have had this happen in myself where I was involved in a discussion that became heated and part of me stepped back and calmly witnessed the outward part of me becoming angry. It was interesting and the witness even thought it a bit comical, but it didn't really feel all that healthy. At least, it left me wondering if unskillful use of such an ability could lead to serious problems.
Destiny! Destiny! No escaping destiny!
"...destiny is what happens. There is no thwarting of destiny. You mean to say everybody's life is totally determined at his birth? What a strange idea! Were it so, the power that determines would see to it that nobody should suffer." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
There are two great points here. First, destiny happens. We assume that everything is cause and effect, but Nisargadatta does not. It's like the sole survivor of an airplane crash who asks "what are the odds?" The answer is, one hundred percent, because that is what happened. My path is my destiny and my destiny is my path, but that does not necessarily imply predetermination or a supreme being or even some karmic law - it is just what it is. Accept it and keep stepping!
The second relates back to theistic philosophies. There is a question of why a God would allow people to suffer and the answers range from there being no God, to God being judgmental and vengeful, to God being like a parent who, with great love, allows his children to live their own lives and make their own decisions and merely loves and supports them through whatever results. It seems to me that the notion that there is a God and that there is absolute determinism cannot coincide. If there is a God, then there must be free will. Well, unless God is a real sicko. Of course, I personally still maintain that there is no God and there is nonetheless either free will or so vastly many factors that must be taken into account to absolutely resolve determinism that it is indistinguishable from free will (think quantum mechanics and halving the distance between two objects).
"Destiny! Destiny! No escaping destiny!" from the movie Young Frankenstein
There are two great points here. First, destiny happens. We assume that everything is cause and effect, but Nisargadatta does not. It's like the sole survivor of an airplane crash who asks "what are the odds?" The answer is, one hundred percent, because that is what happened. My path is my destiny and my destiny is my path, but that does not necessarily imply predetermination or a supreme being or even some karmic law - it is just what it is. Accept it and keep stepping!
The second relates back to theistic philosophies. There is a question of why a God would allow people to suffer and the answers range from there being no God, to God being judgmental and vengeful, to God being like a parent who, with great love, allows his children to live their own lives and make their own decisions and merely loves and supports them through whatever results. It seems to me that the notion that there is a God and that there is absolute determinism cannot coincide. If there is a God, then there must be free will. Well, unless God is a real sicko. Of course, I personally still maintain that there is no God and there is nonetheless either free will or so vastly many factors that must be taken into account to absolutely resolve determinism that it is indistinguishable from free will (think quantum mechanics and halving the distance between two objects).
"Destiny! Destiny! No escaping destiny!" from the movie Young Frankenstein
Many steps, one arriving
"There is no question of failure, neither in the short run nor in the long. It is like traveling a long and arduous road in an unknown country. Of all the innumerable steps there is only the last which brings you to your destination. Yet you will not consider all previous steps as failures. Each brought you nearer to your goal, even when you had to turn back to bypass an obstacle,. In reality each step brings you to your goal, because to be always on the move, learning, discovering, unfolding, is your eternal destiny. Living is life's only purpose." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Yes! It always seems to me that the moment of enlightenment gets so much attention as being a simple moment, as if we all make too much work of the path and we should just snap our fingers and be enlightened. But, what is always forgotten in this is all the many, many steps taken to get to the point where one steps across that threshold. Even the Buddha had thousands of lifetimes and, even if you don't believe in rebirth, he spent six years in intensive practice before he himself got to that one step that carried him across to the beyond. Each of us has our own path and we must take all the steps on that path, however mundane or even unnecessary they may seem. That's just the way it is. May we stumble onto the fork which is the shortest of the unique path that lays before each of us.
Yes! It always seems to me that the moment of enlightenment gets so much attention as being a simple moment, as if we all make too much work of the path and we should just snap our fingers and be enlightened. But, what is always forgotten in this is all the many, many steps taken to get to the point where one steps across that threshold. Even the Buddha had thousands of lifetimes and, even if you don't believe in rebirth, he spent six years in intensive practice before he himself got to that one step that carried him across to the beyond. Each of us has our own path and we must take all the steps on that path, however mundane or even unnecessary they may seem. That's just the way it is. May we stumble onto the fork which is the shortest of the unique path that lays before each of us.
duality, non-duality and beyond
"The undisturbed state of being is bliss; the disturbed state is what appears as the world. In non-duality there is bliss; in duality -- experience. What comes and goes is experience with its duality of pain and pleasure. Bliss is not to be known. One is always bliss, but never blissful. Bliss is not an attribute." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
So, are duality and non-duality both existential and not the unmanifest beyond? The unmanifest beyond is not non-dual because non-duality is a state? Then, perhaps "I Am" does not imply the unmanifest beyond, but the state of non-duality. Even "I Am", then, is not absolute, and is, therefore, inferior.
So, are duality and non-duality both existential and not the unmanifest beyond? The unmanifest beyond is not non-dual because non-duality is a state? Then, perhaps "I Am" does not imply the unmanifest beyond, but the state of non-duality. Even "I Am", then, is not absolute, and is, therefore, inferior.
Philosophy?
"The world itself is contact -- the totality of all contacts actualized in consciousness. The spirit touches matter and consciousness results. Such consciousness, when tainted with memory and expectation, becomes bondage. Pure experience does not bind; experience caught between desire and fear is impure and creates karma." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
I guess this is Nisargadatt's equivalent of dependent origination, with a slant on karma thrown in.
I guess this is Nisargadatt's equivalent of dependent origination, with a slant on karma thrown in.
Tuesday, April 6, 2010
Teaching and guidance
In teaching, there is a difference between general discourse and guidance given specifically from a teacher to a student or practitioner. A discourse is universally true and the consumer receives the teaching with the perspective that it is simple truth which needs to be understood but which may or may not have particular applicability to the practitioner at that moment. Guidance contains a specific message for a specific person in the context of a particular need or difficulty, and is meant to illicit a certain response in the student. While truth in guidance is still pristine, the custom packaging may shade this truth and even make it appear to conflict with other teachings from the same teacher. The truth of guidance lies in how well it fits with the need of a student and causes that change, shift, opening, understanding, insight or alteration of practice which the seeker needs at that point.
It is probably of some value to remember this when reading a book like "I Am That" which is a collection of teachings given each as guidance to an individual seeker. The guidance holds truth, but the knife may be twisted to create a specific incision, and the underlying truth may not be something I need at the moment or may not be packaged in a way that has meaning for me. The same is probably true of the open satsang format. Of course, I must still be on guard for the false and remember that real truth is known, and proven, experientially.
It is probably of some value to remember this when reading a book like "I Am That" which is a collection of teachings given each as guidance to an individual seeker. The guidance holds truth, but the knife may be twisted to create a specific incision, and the underlying truth may not be something I need at the moment or may not be packaged in a way that has meaning for me. The same is probably true of the open satsang format. Of course, I must still be on guard for the false and remember that real truth is known, and proven, experientially.
The value of books
Words are words; teaching is teaching. The adage that tells us we cannot attain enlightenment from reading books is meant to say that seeing the truth, knowing truth, is experiential. But, the words of teachers, masters and gurus, whether spoken or written, help me evolve towards enlightenment. A teacher once said that meditation does not cause enlightenment, but it makes it more likely. So, while experiential practice is paramount, I should not discount the conditioning, the training and preparation of the mind. I believe it is a necessary component and, anyway, it improves my odds.
Monday, April 5, 2010
Pulling weeds
OK, once and for all (for now) I reject the position that the existential self does not exist, is not real, is not tangible and significant within the confines of birth and death. The existential self is real, if only existentially so, and the constant effort to disintegrate the self by stealing all relative words into a new language of not self, non-dualism, or any other perspective is an annoyance that is, for me, distinctly counterproductive. It is a bit like being hoodwinked while being aware that the smiling culprit is blowing smoke up my ass. You can introduce new terms or phrases, or even specify that you are using words in a special context where they have a peculiar inference, but you cannot subordinate the entire English language to your narrow purpose. Harrumph!
If, instead of these games, I simply imagine myself as a temporal manifestation of the unmanifest beyond, then my mind, at least, can dislodge and move forward. It raises several questions or perspectives that become interesting to me, at least intellectually.
The first question is an old question: if the temporal self is a manifestation, then when it dissolves into the unmanifest, bliss will be constituted in the total absence of self (consciousness, experience, etc.) and if I am not there to enjoy it, then why do I want to quit this bundle of experiences, however tumultuous and inadequate they may be?
If we are all manifest from the same beyond, then we are all one in one beyondness. Looking at it from the perspective of the unmanifest, we are each just temporary manifestations from the one, pervasive I Am. From the viewpoint of individual manifestations, there is duality and multiplicity and we are each unique individuals; but from the perspective of the unmanifest, everything conjured up by consciousness is part of the oneness and not differentiated - there is no duality. This suggests that enlightenment is both coming to know this truth and also fundamentally changing one's perspective from that of the individual to that of the unmanifest.
This perspective of the unmanifest also suggests that for me to become liberated is a trivial, even inconsequential attainment because the ocean is full of waves and perpetually raises up wave after wave. Since we are all I Am, then I Am can only become liberated when all manifestations both dissolve and stop being reborn. Nisargadatta's I Am is stuck in a relentless suffering unless every manifest being becomes liberated. Let the last one out of the room of the manifest turn out the light of consciousness. What a hopeless proposition for I, I Am, and all manifest beings! Excuse me, would you all kindly start meditating so I can one day be liberated?
OK, so lets' state it again differently and see if it gets any better. Nisargadatta's I Am is at lest an inference to the unmanifest beyond. So, regardless of our multiplicity and duality as existential beings, if we each investigate the source of our selves, we will all discover the same unmanifest reality, the source of all conditioned reality, and, therefore, the selfsame I Am. And in that moment of realization, advaita is proved - that we are all manifest of the same I Am is obvious and the implication is that thereafter, when I consider my existential self from the perspective of the I Am, then I can no longer be substantively differentiated from every other manifest being for all are I Am. Further, no self has any more or less value than another self, and the acts between the manifest selves are the I Am acting on the I Am. I cannot harm another because there is no other for me to harm. I Am all and I Am all I Am.
So what?
Well, first, this knowledge, if it is even true, is of limited value because it is not experiential. Just as the finger points at the moon, and we need teachers and their words and guidance in whatever form or medium, so knowledge, however acquired, helps us on our path. For me, knowledge and understanding help to remove obstacles to progress. Every change in perspective gives me the chance to see another door, another passage. Perhaps this is the cultivation of the Buddha's Right View. However, I do believe that just as insight opens the mind, it is experience of truth that will drag me across the threshold. It is the unexplainable yet unquestionable experience of the ineffable reality that will bring absolute liberation...
... of the self. Holy shit! I Am can realize myself and disintegrate into I Am but I Am not free of these manifest warts until all of you do the same! We are like a rash on the butt of the unmanifest: we may cure a spot, but meanwhile the rash keeps spreading and getting uglier and we need to treat, to cure, the entire rash. Oh, sigh!
I wonder if a spot of the rash can be cured in such a way that the cure sort of infects more of the rash? The Buddha infected a big chunk of the rash and still the rash is far bigger now and the cure has been almost lost. What am I left? The hopeless path of the Bodhisattva or the insignificant attainment of self realization, of my own, minuscule liberation?
Perhaps when pulling weeds in the strawberry patch, it is best not to cogitate on the entire farm - just keep pulling weeds.
If, instead of these games, I simply imagine myself as a temporal manifestation of the unmanifest beyond, then my mind, at least, can dislodge and move forward. It raises several questions or perspectives that become interesting to me, at least intellectually.
The first question is an old question: if the temporal self is a manifestation, then when it dissolves into the unmanifest, bliss will be constituted in the total absence of self (consciousness, experience, etc.) and if I am not there to enjoy it, then why do I want to quit this bundle of experiences, however tumultuous and inadequate they may be?
If we are all manifest from the same beyond, then we are all one in one beyondness. Looking at it from the perspective of the unmanifest, we are each just temporary manifestations from the one, pervasive I Am. From the viewpoint of individual manifestations, there is duality and multiplicity and we are each unique individuals; but from the perspective of the unmanifest, everything conjured up by consciousness is part of the oneness and not differentiated - there is no duality. This suggests that enlightenment is both coming to know this truth and also fundamentally changing one's perspective from that of the individual to that of the unmanifest.
This perspective of the unmanifest also suggests that for me to become liberated is a trivial, even inconsequential attainment because the ocean is full of waves and perpetually raises up wave after wave. Since we are all I Am, then I Am can only become liberated when all manifestations both dissolve and stop being reborn. Nisargadatta's I Am is stuck in a relentless suffering unless every manifest being becomes liberated. Let the last one out of the room of the manifest turn out the light of consciousness. What a hopeless proposition for I, I Am, and all manifest beings! Excuse me, would you all kindly start meditating so I can one day be liberated?
OK, so lets' state it again differently and see if it gets any better. Nisargadatta's I Am is at lest an inference to the unmanifest beyond. So, regardless of our multiplicity and duality as existential beings, if we each investigate the source of our selves, we will all discover the same unmanifest reality, the source of all conditioned reality, and, therefore, the selfsame I Am. And in that moment of realization, advaita is proved - that we are all manifest of the same I Am is obvious and the implication is that thereafter, when I consider my existential self from the perspective of the I Am, then I can no longer be substantively differentiated from every other manifest being for all are I Am. Further, no self has any more or less value than another self, and the acts between the manifest selves are the I Am acting on the I Am. I cannot harm another because there is no other for me to harm. I Am all and I Am all I Am.
So what?
Well, first, this knowledge, if it is even true, is of limited value because it is not experiential. Just as the finger points at the moon, and we need teachers and their words and guidance in whatever form or medium, so knowledge, however acquired, helps us on our path. For me, knowledge and understanding help to remove obstacles to progress. Every change in perspective gives me the chance to see another door, another passage. Perhaps this is the cultivation of the Buddha's Right View. However, I do believe that just as insight opens the mind, it is experience of truth that will drag me across the threshold. It is the unexplainable yet unquestionable experience of the ineffable reality that will bring absolute liberation...
... of the self. Holy shit! I Am can realize myself and disintegrate into I Am but I Am not free of these manifest warts until all of you do the same! We are like a rash on the butt of the unmanifest: we may cure a spot, but meanwhile the rash keeps spreading and getting uglier and we need to treat, to cure, the entire rash. Oh, sigh!
I wonder if a spot of the rash can be cured in such a way that the cure sort of infects more of the rash? The Buddha infected a big chunk of the rash and still the rash is far bigger now and the cure has been almost lost. What am I left? The hopeless path of the Bodhisattva or the insignificant attainment of self realization, of my own, minuscule liberation?
Perhaps when pulling weeds in the strawberry patch, it is best not to cogitate on the entire farm - just keep pulling weeds.
Saturday, April 3, 2010
To dualism or not
"All the dreams are superimposed over a common world. To some extent they shape and influence each other. The basic unity operates in spite of all." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
While Nisargadatta is a non-dualist, statements like this leave me really wondering. Most often I understand him as saying that everything that is manifest exists in duality and only the un-manifest is non-dual. He also says that everything, the world and everything in it, is "I Am" and that without manifestations from his "I Am-ness", the world and everything that is manifest dissolves. But, here, I read that there is a common world that is apart from all that we manifest. Hmm, or that what we manifest overlaps - and when the last person leaves the room and turns out the lights, the manifest world goes dark. But, doesn't that the world manifest in I Am effects the world manifest in You Is? That makes me think of dualism. Or, more likely, the more I try to understand Nisargadatta, the more confused I become. Sometimes, the gurus talk in koans: the understanding is in realizing one cannot understand and the only nonsense is in trying.
While Nisargadatta is a non-dualist, statements like this leave me really wondering. Most often I understand him as saying that everything that is manifest exists in duality and only the un-manifest is non-dual. He also says that everything, the world and everything in it, is "I Am" and that without manifestations from his "I Am-ness", the world and everything that is manifest dissolves. But, here, I read that there is a common world that is apart from all that we manifest. Hmm, or that what we manifest overlaps - and when the last person leaves the room and turns out the lights, the manifest world goes dark. But, doesn't that the world manifest in I Am effects the world manifest in You Is? That makes me think of dualism. Or, more likely, the more I try to understand Nisargadatta, the more confused I become. Sometimes, the gurus talk in koans: the understanding is in realizing one cannot understand and the only nonsense is in trying.
Amen!
"A man who claims to know what is good for others is dangerous." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
The world could use a heavy dose of this message. I'm sure it would be good for them! :)
The world could use a heavy dose of this message. I'm sure it would be good for them! :)
I am not that
"I am nothing, and nothing is afraid of no thing. On the contrary, everything is afraid of the Nothing, for when a thing touches Nothing, it becomes nothing. It is like a bottomless well, whatever falls into it, disappears." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Which still doesn't resolve the question of why I should want to unbecome.
Which still doesn't resolve the question of why I should want to unbecome.
wei wu wei
Questioner: "Striving is painful."
Maharaj: "You make it so by seeking results. Strive without seeking, struggle without greed."
- I Am That
Maharaj: "You make it so by seeking results. Strive without seeking, struggle without greed."
- I Am That
Freedom from desire
"Desires are just waves in the mind. You know a wave when you see one. A desire is just a thing among many. I feel no urge to satisfy it, no action needs be taken on it. Freedom from desire means this: the compulsion to satisfy is absent." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Enlightened or comatose?
Questioner: "And if I desire nothing, not even the Supreme?"
Maharaj: "Then you are as good as dead, or you are the Supreme."
— I Am That
Maharaj: "Then you are as good as dead, or you are the Supreme."
— I Am That
Meditation in life
"Deliberate daily exercise in discrimination between the true and the false and renunciation of the false is meditation." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Free of emotion
"Action, in which you are not emotionally involved and which is beneficial and does not cause suffering will not bind you." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
But, doesn't that mean that action taken out of compassion will bind me?
But, doesn't that mean that action taken out of compassion will bind me?
What could I possibly conceive?
"Nothing of value can happen to a mind which knows exactly what it wants. For nothing the mind can visualise and want is of much value." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
They aren't real either
"Having given reality to the picture on the screen, you love its people and suffer for them and seek to save them." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
This seems to suggest that there is no need to have compassion because people, like everything else in our experience, is merely part of the dream, the illusion. I can taste it, but it is hard to swallow.
This seems to suggest that there is no need to have compassion because people, like everything else in our experience, is merely part of the dream, the illusion. I can taste it, but it is hard to swallow.
When there's nothing left....
"It must be seen directly, by giving up all search for signs and approaches. When all names and forms have been given up, the real is with you. You need not seek it. Plurality and diversity are the play of the mind only. Reality is one." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
Negate everything and when nothing is left to negate, then the nothingness that is not left is everything. I think it is a quote from Sherlock Holmes that went something like, "when you have eliminated all possibilities, then whatever is left, however unlikely, must be the truth."
Negate everything and when nothing is left to negate, then the nothingness that is not left is everything. I think it is a quote from Sherlock Holmes that went something like, "when you have eliminated all possibilities, then whatever is left, however unlikely, must be the truth."
The supreme is not a state
"The world and the mind are states of being. The supreme is not a state. It pervades all states, but it is not a state of something else." - Nisargadatta, I Am That
This makes a lot of sense; but, mostly, talk like this raises more questions in my little brain than it answers. If it is not a state, then I must not be aware of being there; in fact, there is not there and no I to be. Of course, then why would "I" want to be there? Or, should I say, be not being not there?
This makes a lot of sense; but, mostly, talk like this raises more questions in my little brain than it answers. If it is not a state, then I must not be aware of being there; in fact, there is not there and no I to be. Of course, then why would "I" want to be there? Or, should I say, be not being not there?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
