I read Nisargadatta and try to understand his image of non-duality, but I don't. The notion seems to be that if we are all of the unmanifest, then in that context we are all one and everything is of the unmanifest non-dual real. Thus, "I Am" implies the beyond, the unmanifest. I guess each of us, in our I Am-ness, is the same beyond, therefore we are all one in the context of the beyond. In fact, we are not We Are, but the undefinable unmanifest.
However, to me, in our state of being manifest, we are in a temporary state of duality. I can accept that when the wave crests and many drops of water are cast up into the air as individual drops, they are all still of the ocean, a great oneness, and that when they fall back into the ocean they loose their individuality but not their separateness, their duality, even though they do not loose their absolute essence because they are and always were the ocean. Still, in that temporal state, they are, in my mind, separate.
That still leaves the notion of a non-dual, non-state that is absolute reality and is beyond, far beyond, completely beyond consciousness. OK, I will accept that as a stipulation. But, it still leaves me that nagging question. If the unmanifest is beyond consciousness and there is no concept of self or awareness of self, how does it differ from the fundamental notion behind nihilism? If I am not aware that I am in bliss, what is the difference and why do I want to go there?
Sunday, March 28, 2010
Monday, March 22, 2010
Words and concepts
I have come to think that one problem I have in understanding the wise - gurus, realized or enlightened individuals - is that they take words that have definite meaning to me, change their definition, and then try to bend my mind to this new meaning. My mind resists perhaps not because it has difficulty with the new concept but because it must first invalidate a concept the mind knows to be true in a specific context. For example, let us consider what is real. Thus far in life I have worked with the understanding that what I can see, touch, hear, perceive or scientifically detect, if not presented by some trickery of illusion, is real. But, a guru will tell me all this is not real; rather it is all illusion or delusion. Such a guru will say that if we remove all that the mind can detect, perceive, conjure or imagine, then what is left is real. To accept this notion, I must first accept that the world, the universe, indeed all of us and everything are not real. I want to suggest instead that all I have until now considered real continues to be real, but only in a temporal, changing, impermanent and insubstantial reality; that due to its inherent inadequacy, this existential reality is fraught with suffering and happiness is fleeting and fragile. From this perspective, I am now able to more easily consider that there is another reality that is unchanging, beyond mind, self and consciousness, free from sense and sense object, from comparison, judgment and emotion. Thus, it's not necessary for me to tear apart and invalidate the reality I know to be true in this world, but merely to tame this reality, to moderate its significance and open to the concept of what is unchangeably real; to a profound reality where truth is exactly one. An ineffable non-state beyond the supramundane, where the only reality is truth and the only truth is what is real. We agree that words are inadequate for such discussions, so let us not make the discussion conceptually impossible. We could use different words. We could differentiate the absolute from the existential and absolutely real from existentially real.
Saturday, March 20, 2010
I am
Let us presume that I am consciousness. Consciousness is bound to the senses and their interaction with sense objects. Through them, consciousness becomes intertwined with likes and dislikes, craving and aversion, desire, hate, ill-will, greed. Thus, from consciousness springs happiness, the quest for happiness, unhappiness and fear. If it turns out that I am not consciousness, that I am only temporarily experiencing consciousness, then I am-ness might become free of consciousness, and with it craving and desire and aversion and hate and fear. What is left? What is I am?
Protest
Being against, standing against, has no value. It only tells others they are wrong. It tears down and divides but does nothing to improve or to foster harmony, peace, compassion or even responsibility. Being for ignores the negative and promotes the positive. It is the voice of hope, encouragement and betterment. It gives peope the opportunity to choose a different path instead of defending or justifying their current position. It promotes harmony, where love and compassion can grow. But, being for implies the responsibility of standing for - it may require action.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
